Ice Station Zero (Revisited)

The Polar Bears are doing just fine
“Polar Bear Jumping- Arturo de Frias Marques” by Bering Land Bridge National Preserve is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0

I wrote a few notes on Warble Gloaming recently, and with the gloomfest that is COP26 looming I thought it might be time to revisit them. Here’s the first, which I’ve named after an Alistair MacLean novel. It’s best not to take the pronouncements of Impending Doom too seriously!

Idly browsing the Interweb the other day, I came across this BBC article on the terrible outlook for the ice sheet around the North Pole: Arctic summers ice-free ‘by 2013’

Well worth a few moments of your time – it appears that within 5-6 years, the northern polar waters could be ice-free in the summer. Indeed, the scientist quoted says that previous studies have underestimated the melting. I’m convinced! There’s just one thing that’s bothering me, as Columbo used to say. The report is from 2007 and the ice-free year is predicted to be 2013:

The scientist concerned, Professor Wieslaw Maslowski, is still engaged in Arctic research: NPS Researchers Play Leading Roles in Massive Arctic Study

This is a project called the Multidisciplinary drifting Observatory for the Study of Arctic Climate (or MOSAiC for short). It’s a year-long expedition, involving the Research Vessel Polarstern. They plan to get themselves frozen into the ice and stay there for a year. The 600 scientists on the trip will be supported by several other ships including the Akademik Federov, an ice-breaker.

Let me say that again. In 2019, six years after the date when Professor Maslowski predicted that the Arctic would be ice-free, he went back Up North and he took an ice-breaker with him.

Has the man no sense of irony?
The shade of Victor Meldrew comes unbidden to mind, declaiming, ‘I don’t belieeeeeeeeeeve it!’

Just to put ice on the cake (sorry) it has been reported that the icebreaker supply ship is having trouble resupplying the Polarstern because the Arctic ice is too thick, at about 5 feet. It appears that the supply ship was using too much fuel breaking the non-existent ice and after getting to the Polarstern it would need refuelling in order to get back.

Aid is on its way to an icebreaker struggling near the North Pole
Mosaic resupplied despite adverse conditions

I thought this was very funny, and it made me ask:

– Did the 2007 prediction come true? (An easy one, this.)
– How could he have got it so spectacularly wrong?
– How did Professor Maslowski get funding for his current venture?
– Should the failed prediction affect how we respond to his, and other, climate predictions?
– Indeed, what, apart from the date and elapse of time, is different between the 2007 prediction and current, equally doom-laden, climate apocalypse forecasts?
And last but not least:
– How many climate alarmist predictions have actually come true?

© Jim Walshe 2021